Dunstan blocks new holiday lets amid resident concerns. Fifty-five percent of homes are already rentals.
Fifty-five percent of Dunstan’s homes are already holiday rentals. The Craster plan restricts new houses and favors homes for permanent residents instead. Northumberland’s plan limits second homes, too. It applies where over 20% lack permanent residents.
Council planners thought holiday lets differed from second homes. Stuart Palmer, the applicant’s agent, agreed at the meeting. He said the goal was a holiday spot, not second homes. Stays would exceed £3,500 weekly, he claimed.
Adam Shanley said the meeting was repetitive. He noted many opposed the plans, with 124 objections. Councillor Renner-Thompson feared a bad precedent. He warned approval could affect the whole country.
His ward parishes already exceed 20% holiday lets. He mentioned Cornwall and the Lake District could be impacted. He insisted they must refuse the application. Councillor Mather agreed it was not appropriate.
Mather highlighted the community’s effort creating their plan. He said areas risk losing residents. He added that weekend visitors don’t invest locally. He called 55% holiday lets unacceptable, and urged listening to the community.
Councillor Pattison suggested refusal due to plan opposition. Members unanimously rejected the proposal. Martin Smith, Craster’s council chair, was delighted at the refusal. He said it upheld their plan and local policies.
Jackie Reeves, a Dunstan resident, was proud of the community. She said they voiced concerns with numerous objections and hopes this ends the matter. She believes coastal villages need protection.