An Aberdeenshire man lost his case for hedge trimming after claiming it ruined barbecues due to excessive shade.
The man wanted to barbecue and let his kids play. He complained to the Aberdeenshire Council, because Scotland’s High Hedge Act deals with such issues. The council, however, did not side with him.
He said he had asked his neighbor to cut the hedge. The neighbor initially agreed to trim it, but changed their mind after talking to their gardener. They worried trimming would harm the hedge.
The man said the neighbor’s agreement showed the height was excessive. He missed enjoying the sun in his garden in the evening. The hedge’s growth over 15 years cast shade, which ruined summer fun for his children. He spent money to improve the garden for his kids.
Now, they must go inside early due to lack of light. Even during hot summer days, they eat inside because of shade. His partner can’t enjoy the sun after work either.
Council officials looked at the properties. They saw the hedge cast shadows from 3 p.m. on, preventing some sunlight from entering the garden. By 7 p.m., the whole garden was in shadow.
The council only asked the neighbor to trim a little. They said 45 cm would have minimal impact. They felt the hedge screened both properties, ensured privacy, and prevented overlooking, and that trimming it would not improve his enjoyment.