More than 5,000 appeals were lodged against Derby bus lane fines, impacting drivers and raising questions about signage.
The council issued almost 100,000 fines, and stricter rules began in late 2021. Corporation Street has had restrictions since the pandemic, where only buses, taxis, cyclists, and walkers can use it from 7 AM to 7 PM, with cameras and signs warning drivers.
A violation could mean a £70 fine, but paying quickly can reduce the fine amount. The Local Democracy Reporting Service requested this data using the Freedom of Information Act, asking about fines and appeals for this bus lane.
The council said 5,145 appeals occurred since February 1, 2023, as people wanted to challenge their £70 fine. Due to data protection laws older data could not be provided, but the council also shared appeal outcomes. Out of the 1,868 concluded appeals, 556 won and the remaining 1,312 appeals were lost.
People noted the large sum of fine money collected, and some have come to believe the signage may be inadequate. One person unsuccessfully appealed their fine, questioning the fine amount relative to the signage quality. Another person suggested the lane is only for revenue, stating that working signage would not generate so much money.
Someone else felt empathy for those fined, suggesting that drivers did not see the signs. However, the council claims their signage is very clear, and independent adjudicators agreed with the council’s view.
According to the council, the existing signage exceeds the requirements. They state that the bus lane reduces traffic, aids public transit, cuts air pollution, and creates a nicer area for walkers.